LAST POST: A TOUCH OF HEAVEN

Rev. Dr. Kate Winters, “Dwelling in Presence,” February 9, 2024

A shooting star greeted me as I opened the back door to the deck this very early morning. First, I took in a quick breath of surprise and wonder. Taken unawares, I experienced beauty and blessing. Second, when my brain started to engage, I realized that in that flash of a moment with the tiny trail of light, I actually accomplished what makes me, and all of us, most human. Out of this random encounter, I made meaning.

Think about it. I don’t know where the light came from or what it actually was. It could have been a tiny speck flung from a meteor across the galaxy. It could also have been a piece of space junk falling down to earth, entering our atmosphere. But what do we commonly call these things? Falling stars, shooting stars, signs of good luck. Some of us make wishes on them, feeling an unusual power in the sighting. Some simply stare in awe, waiting for another touch of heaven to descend. In any case, this is an event that does not go unnoticed and unmarked, but somehow changes us at the same time that we make our own meaning of it.

As for me, I felt my heart fill with light and gratitude. It was a sign of something that I’ve learned more surely as I have written this blog in my first year of retirement. Staying present, or “dwelling in presence,” brings not only meaning, but joy to our nights and days, dawns and twilights. To know blessing, we must be ready to receive it, open and aware, even in the midst of triple bypasses and pain. Every bit of life is precious. In every second is meaning to be found. We only need to open doors to the darkness, feel the cold air on our skin, and catch the falling star. Amen.

Note: This is the last post for “Dwelling in Presence.”I will seek another way to connect with myself and you!Thank you for taking this year-long journey with me.   

INTENTION

Rev. Dr. Kate Winters, “Dwelling in Presence,” December 29, 2023

I woke up thinking about my mother this morning During our daily phone call during her retirement, she would usually tell me what she had done that day. ”I cleared out the drawer underneath my desk,” or “I emptied out the closet in dad’s old office.”  She said it with a satisfied sense of accomplishment, often adding “I have to do at least one thing a day, then I can rest.” I never really understood why she couldn’t rest to begin with, after all she was retired.

I’m starting to get it. One of the challenging things I have found in this stage of life is that after so many years of a packed calendar, I now have a lot of empty spaces. As someone who has always longed for more solitude and silence in her life, you would think that this is a good thing. At first, it was glorious (minus the detour for heart surgery), but after a while, I realized something. Although I was still basking in the silence of the mornings, meditating, reading, and writing, by noon I began to feel restless, and even, dare I say it, bored!

Yes, I know, there are many things I can be doing, good work to volunteer for, justice to advocate for, peace to demonstrate for, democracy to protect. And yes, I know I am not done with all of that, but I do not want to simply redo an earlier phase of life without knowing what this one is for. I could easily once again get caught up in a whirlwind before I ever find my ground. Neither do I want to float through half of my days wondering what I’m still here for. This is not restful, it is disorienting. 

So, back to Ann, my mother. I think mom firgured out a key to a successful transition to retirement. After days filled with service in her occupation as director of volunteers in a large nursing home/assisted living facility, she may have felt unmoored as I do in open time. There is something, however, that can stem that feeling whatever you are, or are not, currently engaged in. Livng with intention. Each day she seemed to set an intention for her day, whether it be to clear out a drawer or a closet, visit a friend, anything that raised her motivation and feeling of accomplishment when done. 

This is different than just “keeping busy.” Setting an intention raises one’s focus and engages the will. Why is this important? My recent experiences of restlessness and boredom feel like having lost not only the energy, but the will, to do or be anything. I may have a number of admirable goals, but somehow have lost the ability to reach toward them. I am living much of my day without a sense of intention, without making a firm decision, to change my circumstances or anyone else’s.

Mom, I understand now why you couldn’t rest until you got something done, until you accomplished your intended goal. It fed your desire to be of use, to be of service, without which you would always be restless and a little bored. You knew you still had it in you to accomplish what you set out to do. And you always did do wonderful things with your life, inspiring your friends and family. 

So now, it is my turn. In this retirement phase, I need to return to living with intention. I can start small – such as handling one of the piles of folders in my hermitage, filing or recycling as need be, not expecting to get everything done at once. I may feel accomplished enough to take on another tomorrow. But only if I start my day with intention. I wish I had my mother to call and talk about it. But it will feel good to exercise the will in small ways, because I feel bigger challenges coming. I want to be able to say “yes” with all my heart. 

  

ROBAI-SHIN and the PURPLE SWEATER

Rev. Dr. Kate Winters, “Dwelling in Presence,” November 29, 2023

I wasn’t planning on writing this morning but I am so taken by something I’m reading that my heart is fluttering. This used to happen to me once in a while when I was studying as something would strike me in a way that I knew my sight had been widened and my thinking changed. I could barely sit still, wanting to dance around the library stalls, the dorm room, or the nearby field.

Okay, what is it today? The book is Aging with Wisdom: Reflections, Stories and Teachings by Olivia Ames Hoblitzelle. (Kathleen B., if you are reading this, perhaps this is the book we should read together!) A short two page chapter begins with a quote from Eihei Dogen, the 13th century founder of the Soto School of Buddhism: “You can comprehend all of Buddhism, but you cannot go beyond your abilities and your intelligence unless you have robai-shin, grandmother mind, the mind of great compassion.” Hobitzelle goes on to write that in “East Asian languages, mind and heart are designated by the same word, shin. The grandmother’s heart has been broken open and healed countless times through the hard knocks of life. In through the cracks of disappointment and pain come compasson and loving-kindness.” (p. 27)

For many years I struggled on my spiritual journey when my former images of God just broke down and fell apart. Then about thirty years ago, I began to imagine and relate to God as the “great broken heart of the universe” (now, “cosmos”). The totally open Presence that pours love, forgiveness, and compassion upon all who/that suffer.

This way of thinking rose for me soon after I went through a guided meditation on a retreat. The meditation began by walking through a deep, dark forest, coming upon a cabin, entering, and finding someone there. Anyone. In my heart/mind, I immediately saw an old woman sitting in front of a fireplace knitting. I didn’t want to disturb her. But she looked up and her face was shining, ancient and kind. She took what she had been working on and put it on me – a purple sweater. I somehow knew that it was made just for me. I felt a deep warmth and the meditation ended.

This experience touched me on many levels. As someone who has always had a hard time receiving love, feeling unworthy of it, this generous gift, given with such joy, totally filled my heart. I know I had received a moment of deep healing. The ancient woman herself gave me the first experience of being totally comfortable with a feminine God image. She was love and compassion, tenderness and shelter, safety, and, for me, hope. From her, the broken open God-heart evolved, the heart of an ancient grandmother who was not a stranger to pain, loneliness, or sorrow. A great healer.

In a stunning incidence of serendipity, the week following the retreat I was at an Arts Fair in Madison, Wisconsin. I came across an image that took my breath away. It was a tiny purple sweater mounted on hand-made paper and framed – for what reason I don’t know. Well, maybe I do. It was God’s love delivered straight to me. And yes, I took it home.

I now have to find that work of art in the boxes of my as yet unfinished hermitage room, share it with you, and put it up on my newly painted wall. Why is my heart still beating so fast? I realize I may have finally found a name for my God image – Robai-Shin. And it makes me want to dance!

COME DECEMBER LONGING

Rev. Dr. Kate Winters, “Dwelling in Presence,” November 27, 2023

As the wind howls and the rain pounds upon the already saturated ground, I watch the season evolve outside my window. The very last leaves are being blown off trees and I realize that the next storm may bring a carpet of white to cover them. Not long ago, I wrote about November melancholy. I think this storm is clearing the way for December longing. My heart is gearing up, and I’m beginning to feel its urgency.

Last year this time, I was preparing for the Advent season at The First Church. The most meaningful season as far as I am concerned. The church talks about it as a time of getting ready for the coming of Christ into the world, both at the end of time and as a baby in the manger in Bethlehem. As such, it is a four week period of waiting and hope. But Advent really came alive for me when I began to understand it as a season of longing. A time when we should not only really listen to what we are yearning for deep inside, but when we should talk about these longings with one another.

There is a huge difference between asking someone “What do you want for Christmas?” and “What do you long for at this time?” Our personal wants are too small for this season, while our longings may stretch as wide as the world and as high as the heavens. Lighting the Advent wreath of four candles is a meaningful ritual for naming these longings, often summed up in the words hope, peace, joy and love.

We short circuit this communal spiritual practice however by simply lighting a candle, singing a song, and moving on to the next one. My desire is to find ways to lean into these longings together and flesh them out. We can break open our hearts with one another, risk baring our souls, and then act as the beloved community finding ways to respond to these yearnings for the sake of the world and each other. The result would be incarnation – God breaking into the world through our flesh and blood.

Is it possible to create beloved community on line? Is anyone interested in lighting the candles and sharing your longings? Yes, it would be a challenge. But the world needs our heart’s longing and the will to embrace the earth with all our love.

NOVEMBER MELANCHOLY

Rev. Dr. Kate Winters, “Dwelling in Presence,” November 5, 2023

It is November. I don’t need to look at the calendar to know this. I can feel this month coming from the inside of me. Maybe it is the loss of the vibrantly colored leaves or the hue of the sky and dwindling light, or perhaps it is a physical remembrance of a divorce that was finalized the Tuesday before Thanksgiving so many years ago, for many years this month has been a time of melancholy for me. Just as sounds and sights are revving up for holiday celebrations, inside I feel a kind of revving down, a desire to be silent and alone. At this point, I expect the sadness to sink in and stay for a while.

I used to run from it. I made lots of plans, keeping myself busy and connected. But I have learned over the years that this is just exhausting. It makes more sense and does more good to honor those feelings. Be with them. Now, to be sure, melancholy is not clinical depression. It does not bring me to a place of hopelessness and despair. It does not need to be treated. Neither should it be ignored. I have found that feelings, especially those with no immediate apparent cause, teach a good deal about life, our own lives in particular.

On Saturday, Joel and I were supposed to go to a Fall Sunrise Association meeting with other clergy and lay participants. But my November heart wasn’t in it. So after Joel left, I made up my nest next to the window. As a few leaves flew by, I felt in sync with the autumn scene outside. I too am in a phase of loss. I thought about going out, lying flat on the ground, and sharing this cyclical grief with the earth. But I confess my fear of late season tics kept me inside.

I wondered how I could facilitate whatever it was I was needing to let go. After an hour or so of silence, I knew what I had to do. I turned to the other side of the room and took in the piles of boxes and files full of papers, sermons, presentations, class preparations, retreat plans along with all the books I’ve collected in years of learning and teaching. It is a bit disturbing to see one’s whole life stuffed into cardboard containers. I knew that it was time to begin the sorting, the difficult and time-consuming process of deciding what goes back up on shelves, what can be given to others, and what needs to be donated somewhere or simply tossed.

This room, one half with its fine new shelves and window seat, represents the stage in my life following retirement. I can feel the other side totally weighing me down. It is certainly a major contributor to my melancholy, reminding me of a past I don’t want to forget, but I don’t want to be held back by. Besides, it is time to finishing painting the room, get rid of that “bagel” for “azurite blue”, decide what stays and what goes up on the walls, if anything. This is meant to be the simple hermitage that I’ve been longing for my whole life.

And so, let the emptying begin. I expect it will provide times of sadness as well as moments of great joy. Just a few posts ago, I was beginning a geographical life review on our trip from Maine to Wisconsin and back. Perhaps this will take me on an extended journey of my intellectual development. It helps to think of it that way because I know there is much more ahead, this time more focused on my heart. When I was about twelve, I remember saying that what I wanted to do was to “think more deeply into God than anyone else had ever done!” How is that for adolescent hubris? Well, all these years later, I’ve learned we don’t really “think” our way into God. All those academic programs taught me that. But we are all already in God. What I want to do in this phase of life is deepen that knowing and pass it on. For that I will need to keep preparing my soul and opening my heart. Perhaps November melancholy will transfigure into December joy.

ARRIVAL OF A NEW SEASON

Kate Winters, “Dwelling in Presence,” September 22, 2023

On the cusp of a new season, I open a new journal and begin to write. Why is it so hard to lay ink down on this page? It feels like having a chance for a new beginning and not wanting to mess it up. A new journal, a new season, a new stage of my life. Fall begins tomorrow. I have no doubt that it is ushering me into the autumn of my life.

Perhaps I have been here for a while now, but something has changed. I feel a new sense of acceptance. Certainly, I am no longer young, no hint of the eager star performer I was as a child. I have left behind the promising youthful scholar I was in graduate school. I only have fond memories of the gently radical Catholic minister and preacher I was in my late thirties and early forties called the “Woman Chaplain” at the University of Wisconsin Catholic Center. But I no longer have her stamina or the need to reform the entire Roman Catholic Church.

I continue to embrace my ordination in the United Church of Christ, but after twenty-three more years of pastoring local churches, I have retired from that role. I don’t think it is everything that I am any more. My gaze has simulteously become more inward and more cosmic in scope.

I am definitely moving into a new phase, with new priorities and more subtle energies. What I do know is that I will take all that I love into this new season. My incredible partner Joel, who continues to make every step of our journey together more joyous. A continuing desire to teach and to learn. A yearning for God which has always been the deepest thing about me, and the most honest. As I look up, a spectacular half moon surrounded by a soft mist is shining down on me. The journey into autumn is nothing without the holy mystery of it all. I am blessed.

Heart Sense

Rev. Dr. Kate Winters, “Dwelling in Presence,” September 13, 2023

I haven’t written in a while. It is hard to know how to begin this morning. Anything I say feels trite and unfeeling after these weeks of suffering that sisters and brothers around the world have been through. The ongoing loss of the devastated Maui, total destruction of towns and families in Morocco, violent genocide in Sudan, and thousands of human beings swept out into the Mediterranean Sea in Libya, what horror! I haven’t even mentioned the war in Ukraine and the fierce heat cooking the land and its inhabitants in much of the world. I won’t go into the politics of our nation, both embarassing and infuriating, deflecting attention and draining energy from all the real problems that we face. Or choose not to face.

In conversation at cardiac rehab this week, I was amazed by the number of people who “don’t watch or read the news anymore.” They could rattle off all the football scores from the weekend, but had no idea about the scores of people who died in Libya or Marrakesh. How easy it is for us humans to live lives of distraction, planning our days and nights by what we don’t want to see. Or know. I do not think that this really makes our lives any easier. I know my anxiety would rise not knowing what was going on. For I believe there is a level of awareness in us that links us to all being on this earth. We can either develop this awareness or try to shut it off. The more we develop it, the more human we become. The more we distract ourselves from it, the more we cut ourselves off from growing in care and understanding. Essential human traits.

Why should we care? Because this ability helps to develop our heart sense, which is something we have sadly left undeveloped in our world today. We have educated our minds, but have devalued the knowledge that is key to our hearts, which begins with our innate sense of interconnection. This is an important aspect of the wisdom so desperately needed to address the suffering and the destruction of our earth.

Nothing changes if people with well-nurtured and developed heart sense do not come together to employ this gift. But when they/we do, hope is born. Energy returns. Commitments are made. Change is possible. So my question this morning is: Do I/you live primarily a life of distraction or a life of heart sense?

When you begin to hear the cries of the Libyan people, or to feel the despair of the Moroccans, or suffer the scars of the earth in your own body, do not suffer these on your own. Find others who honor the wisdom of their hearts and begin to grow hope for all being on earth.

COMING TO TERMS

Rev. Dr. Kate Winters, “Dwelling in Presence,” August 23, 2023

It is one of those perfect Maine summer days, low 70’s, crisp air, brilliant blue sky, and two competitive hummingbirds chattering next to me at the feeder. Make that three. A little male just chased the two females into the tree. I thought that season was over!

This is the first day since last year that I am writing in my screen tent on the deck. I don’t really know what took me so long. Although our prairie has been cut down to grass with hay on the side, I am surrounded by pink, purple, and white phlox, hundreds of black-eyed susans, bright orange nasturtium, and can hear our solar-powered fountain gently splashing in the bird bath. Certainly a more pastoral scene than my corner of the couch offered.

Now that I think about it, since retirement I may have been avoiding the spaces I equated with doing my work. I have written many a sermon/message in this tent. The most joyful part of my work hands-down. I also did a lot of liturgy planning and hymn writing at my desk in front of the wide living room window. It always gave me inspiration, like the osprey spreading its wings and the dragon fly lifted on the breeze. The trees in every season spoke to a different phase of the year and the heart. The empty branches rising in prayer and spring leaf buds hinting at rebirth. The dawn sky of Advent wearing the blue of hope and promise. But lately, I have been using the desk only for e-mail or word processing on the computer, never upon which to write. Any creative activity since January was done in one corner of the sofa. I did most of my grieving and my healing there under an afghan made for me by a dear friend. It was my refuge.

So what brings me outside today? What has changed? Perhaps I am moving from denial of what I have lost in the last seven months to acceptance. Joel and I participated in the installation of a colleague as pastor of another church on Sunday. It was strange putting on our clergy robes and stoles once again. But it was a reminder that even though we have let go the position of pastor at First Church, we are still ordained as pastor/teacher in the wider United Church of Christ. We are still called to serve the church and the world. It will simply have to take another form and be in a new place. Isn’t this the pattern of growth? To let go of one particular thing to open our arms to wider experience?

At the beginning of the installation service, the pianist played “Here I Am, Lord.” This was sung at my ordination service in Ohio. I was immediately transported back to that day in Septamber of 2000. It seemed that only yesterday I was taking the vows of ordination and feeling the weight of the hands upon my head as the Spirit was called to fill me and guide me on my way. A part of me was thinking I wish I could do it all over again. On the other hand, a deeper part knows that I am not the same woman anymore, except that I am still burning with a desire to know, love, and serve God in whatever form she manifests herself to me.

Finally, just before I set myself up to write in my tent, I was flipping through TV channels after the news. Sunddenly, there was Josh Fitterling, the new designated interim pastor at The First Church, leading worship on the local access channel. My first impulse was to flip on by, not wanting to deal with my feelings. But then, I just stopped and watched. I noted that he was preaching from the lectern, as I used to do, and not the raised pulpit. And yes, he belonged there. It was his turn to find himself at the heart of that good community. It was his turn to speak. To lead prayer. To love and be loved by the people. It is my turn to sit here on my deck in the summer breeze, listening to the racket of the ravens above me, the zooming by of the hummingbirds, and the whisper deep down in my soul – “Be still. Get ready to open your arms and your heart ever wider.” And I answer, “Yes.”

THE POWER OF A BOOK

Rev. Dr. Kate Winters, “Dwelling in Presence,” August 7, 2023

Have you ever opened a book, begun to read, and found your heart beating faster with the realization that you were about to be changed in some essential way? You surmise that the way you look at the world and your life is about to be expanded, deepened, or blown up all together? The moment stands out in your memory, even if it was decades ago, as a crucial turning point.

I remember clear as day the moment in my junior year of college when I took a book off a shelf in a retreat house I was staying at for the weekend. It was Out of Solitude by Father Henri Nouwen. I took myself somewhere outside to read. It was not a long book, and by the time I got to the end, my whole body and mind felt different. The best I can describe it is as a state of deep longing, an ache to know and to live by what I had just read. The text was both simple and profound.

I have no doubt that that book gave direction to my life, from college to grad school (where I did get to study with Henri), to teaching and ministry. It also took me where I would have the privilege to be advised by Dr. Margaret Farley, RSM at Yale Divinity School, which led to a feminist awakening as well as to the realization that the reason I was so taken by Fr. Nouwen was that he was articulating things that were already singing deep inside my heart. Margaret helped me to see clearly the idol I had erected and enabled me to reclaim my own mind. I am grateful to them both as significant human touchstones in my coming to adulthood.

Certain other books have had similar, if not as clearly momentous, influences on me; Women’s Ways of Knowing by Mary Field Belenky, et. al., Sexism and God-Talk by one of my Ph.D. advisors, Rosemary Radford Ruether, The Evolving Self by Robert Kegan, Adult Faith by James Fowler. All of these from graduate school and seminary days helped to shape my developmental perspective on life and a focus on women’s experience. Then more recently, books by John O’Donohue, J. Philip Newell, Martin Laird, Kathleen Dowling Singh, and others have encouraged the next phase – the aspirational Celtic writer-theologian-contemplative!

What started this whole stream of consciousness was a book I began this morning that instantly had my heart beating in that old “get ready for change” rhythm. Kabir Helminski writes: “Our churches emphasize beliefs rather than experience, emotion rather than transcendent experience, conventional religious behavior rather than inner transformation. We are starved for the food of the soul.” (Living Presence: The Sufi Path to Mindfulness and the Essential Self, p. 11) He also writes that our eduational institutions are solely about intellectual pursuits and collecting head knowledge, not about formation of the heart. When I look back on my academic career, it amazes me how on point this is, even including the work I did for three seminary degrees. As I read Helminski, I realized how much catch up work there is to do to get my heart as prepared and ready for something new as my intellect often is.

One of the first things I learn here is that food for the soul cannot be found solely in solitary pursuits. This is a good reminder and motivator to find myself a new kind of community in this retirement, or help to create one, one that is not satisfied with traditional beliefs or conventional religious behavior. Perhaps this is partly what this blog is all about. But I am becoming aware that the blog itself is not sufficient – I need the physical presence of others on this journey. I also need the couage and will at this time to make myself physically present. I am way too comfortable these days in my own company. But for now, I’ll be at least conversing with Kabir Helminski and the rest of you!

Coming Full Circle

Rev. Kate Winters, Ph.D., “Dwelling in Presence,” July 30, 2023

Born the second child in a family of five, with an older brother and three younger sisters, I took on many traits of an eldest child; an overly developed sense of responsibility, a need to take care of people (including my mother who had her hands full with five children under the age of ten), and a deep desire for the attention of my father in the midst of all those kids. While some children act out to get noticed, I took an opposite tactic: I would be good.

Now goodness meant a couple of things to me. Deeply influenced by the Franciscan Capuchin nuns of my grammar school, I endeavored to be obedient, helpful, and, as much as I could, I would be holy, whatever that meant to an over-eager Roman Catholic child. But good moral behavior was not enough – I would also need to excel in whatever I did. Get the solos in the dance recitals, win the spelling bees, get the best grades in school, which would be certain to have the priests tell me that my father would be very proud when they handed out the report cards. Anything less than perfect meant my father in heaven and on earth would be disappointed in me, at least in my mind, bringing on not guilt, but feelings of shame. It came with the recognition that I was not enough and bound to fail. In other words, I was not the saint I aspired to be, I was only human. The problem with all of this is that I never fully accepted my humanity as lovable.

Why do I rehearse and rehash this past? Some would say that I was being dramatic. I’m an adult now, not the attention seeking “holy ghost” as I was labeled by my siblings. I should just put it all behind me. After all, I am now a teacher and clergyperson myself, therefore should practice what I preach – the worth and dignity of every fallible human and non-human being, and that God is not judgment, but infinite love.

Well, I have learned something in this new retirement stage of being. Life seems to come full circle. Back to when I was only starting out trying to figure out what it was all about. Who and how I am meant to be…now. With approximately six decades of experience behind me, you would think that this would be easy. On the other hand, the patterns I have lived in these years are awfully set in their ways and hard to break. They may have contributed to my current condition – an over-stressed and broken heart. Step one has to be to mend the brokenness, relax, accept, and love all the imperfections, trade in sainthood for simply human. Then, I think, I must learn to allow myself to just be. Could it be that the grace I’ve been helping others to know is meant for me as well?

May it be so, and may I have the humility to receive it.